SC Supreme Court denies rehearing for Baby Veronica case - KTUL.com - Tulsa, Oklahoma - News, Weather & Sports

SC Supreme Court denies rehearing for Baby Veronica case

Posted: Updated:

Provided

CHARLESTON, S.C. - The South Carolina Supreme Court denied Matt and Melanie Capobianco a request for rehearing in their custody case. The state's highest court ruled last month in favor of the Indian Child Welfare Act and affirmed that the couple's 2-year-old adoptive daughter remain in Oklahoma with her biological father Dusten Brown.

The request for the rehearing was the last possible legal step the Capobiancos could take regarding their case within South Carolina's jurisdiction. They have 90 days to appeal to the United States Supreme Court.

According to family friend, Jessica Munday, the couple continues to struggle with the court's decision. "There really are no words to describe the incredible heartbreak, disappointment and pain this family is feeling."

"The dissenting ruling from Justices Kittredge and Hearn says it all," states Munday. "It was clear the court had a very difficult time with this case. It's such a shame that Veronica's best interests had to take a backseat to the Cherokee Nation."

It is not known at this time if the family will appeal to the United States Supreme Court.

Only one Indian Child Welfare Act case has reached the U.S. Supreme Court, which ruled in 1989's Mississippi Band of Choctaw Indians vs. Holyfield that "the tribal court had exclusive jurisdiction over a private adoption even though the mother left the reservation to give birth to twins" and preferred that a non-Native couple raise her children.

In May, the Cherokee Nation petitioned the U.S. Supreme Court to review a U.S. 10th Circuit Court of Appeals' ruling that the Indian Child Welfare Act did not apply to what a three-judge panel termed "temporary" tribal citizenship conferred solely for ICWA purposes. This case also involved a multiracial child and non-Native American adoptive parents. The U.S. Supreme Court denied the Cherokee Nation's request.

Veronica was removed from her Charleston home on New Year's Eve 2011 without any transition period despite repeated requests for one by the couple. The Capobiancos have had no contact with her since that time.

ABC News 4 will have more on this story as it develops.

  • NewsMore>>

  • Sidewalk Plans Scrapped At Gathering Place

    Sidewalk Plans Scrapped At Gathering Place

    It's called The Gathering Place, but changes have been made to the way that some people would have gathered there."We were planning on putting a sidewalk that was gonna connect to this location run it all the way along here all the way up around the circle to 21st street and Veterans Park, get it all tied together," said Paul Zachary.An additional way to access the park, until residents in the neighborhood adjacent to the area said hold on a minute."The problem would be parking on our narrow ...More >>
    It's called The Gathering Place, but changes have been made to the way that some people would have gathered there."We were planning on putting a sidewalk that was gonna connect to this location run it all the way along here all the way up around the circle to 21st street and Veterans Park, get it all tied together," said Paul Zachary.An additional way to access the park, until residents in the neighborhood adjacent to the area said hold on a minute."The problem would be parking on our narrow ...More >>
  • EMSA Issues 4th Medical Heat Alert

    EMSA Issues 4th Medical Heat Alert

    EMSA medics responded to eight patients with suspected heat-related symptoms within a 20 hour period on Tuesday.More >>
    EMSA medics responded to eight patients with suspected heat-related symptoms within a 20 hour period on Tuesday.More >>
  • Video of Accused Shoplifter Goes Viral

    Video of Accused Shoplifter Goes Viral

    An accused shoplifter caught in the act. On another man's cell phone. That video is going viral! It happened outside the Walmart in Coweta.A man named Anthony Smith posted the video on his Facebook page on Sunday. More than 3,800 people shared the video as of Tuesday. According to comments on the social media website, Smith followed a possible shoplifter out of a Coweta Walmart and captured the man quickly throwing a shopping cart full of groceries into the back seat of a gold SUV. The video ...More >>
    An accused shoplifter caught in the act. On another man's cell phone. That video is going viral! It happened outside the Walmart in Coweta.A man named Anthony Smith posted the video on his Facebook page on Sunday. More than 3,800 people shared the video as of Tuesday. According to comments on the social media website, Smith followed a possible shoplifter out of a Coweta Walmart and captured the man quickly throwing a shopping cart full of groceries into the back seat of a gold SUV. The video ...More >>
Powered by WorldNow

P.O. Box 8 Tulsa, OK 74101-0008

Powered by WorldNow

All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Worldnow and KTUL. All Rights Reserved.
For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.